CO129-227 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1886 [6] — Page 537

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

bris been proved by long experience in

Various countries

for

that the best deterrent

criminals is separation.

8. Sept

Perhaps it might be suggested that

before

"the chief is reduced some

the

loist of the prisoners should be carefully

other Scharated from the rest, this in the present gool; or in come other builting t for second or eltart wither to room

gádl

Separation by moving

being

the

found for short sentenced prisoners into another building

as suggested above

Governor

I do not like

When the

refusing this power of flogging gorurora the hand of the good day it is a "matter possibly of life & dealt : but on the other hand it seems to me

they ought to

manage

to clos without it

C.PL

MINUTE PAPER.

Lucas

agree with Morhereas that if

arre built and the separate

new fac

system effectually expreced crime.

preeally he kept under in Washing witheat

canting to conferal punishment for offences

Sugland for which it is not inflicte

and that it is met desirable to remon

rution for hulding

the

Int

535

I think he underrated the difficulty which is caused of the provirnih gtingking & the. mainland and the attraction for Chinori

this is no

criminals to keskeny from the comperatin Ceniency of the law of lelong. reason for lidder, against the hutalis f Chonicce low but it is (a justification for more stringent penal legislation than would be approved in these the abroncs of this peculiar condition of things.

Lexron

Ov

a

I think that Law Kimberley pielded perhaps too much to his Hope Umnipe = pernistut efforts to ablish corporal punishment and the papage in his defatal of 2f hes 1000 puite & Mr. Marsh shew that he was doubtful o the prudence of the course wheel was then adopted. I home When that it is safe to lay down a hand and fort will that what is fred for bylaw

pury', hement for wrione in the way the telmien all cow the cold whaling

thear whalitout

their limalt and the love

that paling has met hen copt in India or

the Straits and I don't sue ety it

in Caylen

E

Edit History

2026-05-25 03:42:15 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
bris been proved by long experience in Various countries for that the best deterrent criminals is separation. 8. Sept Perhaps it might be suggested that before "the chief is reduced some the loist of the prisoners should be carefully other Scharated from the rest, this in the present gool; or in come other builting t for second or eltart wither to room gádl Separation by moving being the found for short sentenced prisoners into another building as suggested above Governor I do not like When the refusing this power of flogging gorurora the hand of the good day it is a "matter possibly of life & dealt : but on the other hand it seems to me they ought to manage to clos without it C.PL MINUTE PAPER. Lucas agree with Morhereas that if arre built and the separate new fac system effectually expreced crime. preeally he kept under in Washing witheat canting to conferal punishment for offences Sugland for which it is not inflicte and that it is met desirable to remon rution for hulding the Int 535 I think he underrated the difficulty which is caused of the provirnih gtingking & the. mainland and the attraction for Chinori this is no criminals to keskeny from the comperatin Ceniency of the law of lelong. reason for lidder, against the hutalis f Chonicce low but it is (a justification for more stringent penal legislation than would be approved in these the abroncs of this peculiar condition of things. Lexron Ov a I think that Law Kimberley pielded perhaps too much to his Hope Umnipe = pernistut efforts to ablish corporal punishment and the papage in his defatal of 2f hes 1000 puite & Mr. Marsh shew that he was doubtful o the prudence of the course wheel was then adopted. I home When that it is safe to lay down a hand and fort will that what is fred for bylaw pury', hement for wrione in the way the telmien all cow the cold whaling thear whalitout their limalt and the love that paling has met hen copt in India or the Straits and I don't sue ety it in Caylen E
Baseline (Original)
bris been proved by long experience in Various countries for that the best deterrent criminals is separation. 8. Sept Perhaps it might be suggested that before "the chief is reduced some the loist of the prisoners should be carefully other Scharated from the rest, this in the present gool; or in come other builting t for second or eltart wither to room gádl Separation by moving being the found for short sentenced prisoners into another building as suggested above Governor I do not like When the refusing this power of flogging gorurora the hand of the good day it is a "matter possibly of life & dealt : but on the other hand it seems to me they ought to manage to clos without it C.PL MINUTE PAPER. Lucas agree with Morhereas that if arre built and the separate new fac system effectually expreced crime. preeally he kept under in Washing witheat canting to conferal punishment for offences Sugland for which it is not inflicte and that it is met desirable to remon rution for hulding the Int 535 I think he underrated the difficulty which is caused of the provirnih gtingking & the. mainland and the attraction for Chinori this is no criminals to keskeny from the comperatin Ceniency of the law of lelong. reason for lidder, against the hutalis f Chonicce low but it is (a justification for more stringent penal legislation than would be approved in these the abroncs of this peculiar condition of things. Lexron Ov a I think that Law Kimberley pielded perhaps too much to his Hope Umnipe = pernistut efforts to ablish corporal punishment and the papage in his defatal of 2f hes 1000 puite & Mr. Marsh shew that he was doubtful o the prudence of the course wheel was then adopted. I home When that it is safe to lay down a hand and fort will that what is fred for bylaw pury', hement for wrione in the way the telmien all cow the cold whaling thear whalitout their limalt and the love that paling has met hen copt in India or the Straits and I don't sue ety it in Caylen E
2026-05-25 03:42:15 · Baseline
View content

bris been proved by long experience in

Various countries

for

that the best deterrent

criminals is separation.

8. Sept

Perhaps it might be suggested that

before

"the chief is reduced some

the

loist of the prisoners should be carefully

other Scharated from the rest, this in the present gool; or in come other builting t for second or eltart wither to room

gádl

Separation by moving

being

the

found for short sentenced prisoners into another building

as suggested above

Governor

I do not like

When the

refusing this power of flogging gorurora the hand of the good day it is a "matter possibly of life & dealt : but on the other hand it seems to me

they ought to

manage

to clos without it

C.PL

MINUTE PAPER.

Lucas

agree with Morhereas that if

arre built and the separate

new fac

system effectually expreced crime.

preeally he kept under in Washing witheat

canting to conferal punishment for offences

Sugland for which it is not inflicte

and that it is met desirable to remon

rution for hulding

the

Int

535

I think he underrated the difficulty which is caused of the provirnih gtingking & the. mainland and the attraction for Chinori

this is no

criminals to keskeny from the comperatin Ceniency of the law of lelong. reason for lidder, against the hutalis f Chonicce low but it is (a justification for more stringent penal legislation than would be approved in these the abroncs of this peculiar condition of things.

Lexron

Ov

a

I think that Law Kimberley pielded perhaps too much to his Hope Umnipe = pernistut efforts to ablish corporal punishment and the papage in his defatal of 2f hes 1000 puite & Mr. Marsh shew that he was doubtful o the prudence of the course wheel was then adopted. I home When that it is safe to lay down a hand and fort will that what is fred for bylaw

pury', hement for wrione in the way the telmien all cow the cold whaling

thear whalitout

their limalt and the love

that paling has met hen copt in India or

the Straits and I don't sue ety it

in Caylen

E

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.